In September of last year, I detailed my struggle with the iPhone, Apple, and how AT&T gave me a free and easy way out of the whole debacle. You can read the whole store here: http://penultimateblog.wordpress.com/2009/05/23/fuck-apple-and-the-iphone-they-rode-in-on/
In the worlds of the late, great Paul Harvey, now here’s the rest of the story.
The Blackberry lasted until December, which was a bit disappointing since I was still riding the “Blackberry From the Toilet Works Better Than iPhone” high, the fact that I even had some type of moral high from that being disappointing in itself. I took it to the AT&T store that had helped me so well before, and the tech there diagnosed the problem: the battery was shot (I’m guessing the toilet had contributed to this somewhat).
To be honest, I was tired of the Blackberry. No, I didn’t miss the iPhone, but I did miss one thing (the only thing?) it did very well: browsing. It surfed the Internet like no other hand-held before it or, from what I’ve seen, since. So I asked the guy what the new hotness in Blackberry’s was, and told him no touchscreen. Well, the new hotness in Blackberry’s IS the touchscreen. There was also something called a Bold, then there was something for $400 that was essentially exactly like the Blackberry I already had, which included a fairly useless Internet Browser. Why have a data plan if you can’t do the Internet? I was becoming unenthusiastic for another Blackberry and started looking around the store for something that could decently display a webpage. Not only that, but if I wanted the blackberry to work with my Exchange server, I needed to spend another $15 a month.
Next to the Blackberry was a jewel of a phone, the Samsung Epix. It ran Windows Mobile 6.1, huge screen, a touch-pad mouse, could sync with Exchange with on a few clicks, and the web-browsing was far better than the Blackberry. It was also $100 cheaper. I handed it to the tech and told him we were going with that one.
“Have you tried Windows Mobile?” he asked.
“No. Why? Does it have problems?”
He looked uneasy, then he said, “No. I’m sure you’ll be happy. I just like the Blackberrys better.”
But I had an Exchange server that my life revolved around, my neighbor loved his WinMo phone, another colleague swore by his, and it was a Samsung to boot. In December 2008, I purchased my Samsung Epix. Two weeks later, when my brother saw mine, he bought the same one.
And that was when the fun began, the word “fun” here meaning a six-month process by which our phones rarely worked for more than 4 hours at a time, of hours on the phone with AT&T, the provider from which we bought the phone, bought insurance for the phone, and which failed not only to solve our problems, but to replace the phone with a workable units.
Over the course of warranty claims by my brother and I, we each received a total of 3 replacement Epix phones. All in all, my brother and I had our hands on 8 Samsung Epixs, and they all had the exact same behavior. The Samsung Epix appears to consistently have the following problems:
1. If the phone is asleep, and an alarm or notification is set, the phone does not wake up. An available update does not completely solve this problem.
2. Wireless connectivity stops working after about an hour connected to a network. The only way to get it back is to restart the phone.
3. Bluetooth, like wireless, is flakey.
4. SLOG dumps start occurring after about 48 hours of usage. Once they start, they don’t stop. The only solution is to pull out the battery. After this happens three or four times, the memory can get corrupted and a hard reset is required. For those unfamiliar with Windows Mobile, a Hard Reset wipes the phone clean, so you have to then put all your info back in.
5. The phone has issues connecting to voicemail regularly.
6. The touchscreen will just stop working, and the phone can’t function without it. The only solution is to pull the battery.
7. The phone will decide it’s just not going to let you answer phone calls anymore. Press the button all you want, but that call is going to voicemail. See item #5.
8. We had a lot of trouble getting Internet to work on the phone. One phone refused to surf the web over wireless, but over the cell network it worked fine. Two of them simply would not surf the Internet at all.
To be fair, the Epix does one thing exceptionally well: the syncing with Exchange was flawless. But that’s Microsoft’s OS taking care of that, not the phone itself. These were business phones and we were having trouble doing business with them. There were many times where people just couldn’t contact us for hours at a time.
AT&T was generally good about replacing the phones the first 4 times and admitted a long list of known problems with the Epix. However, the last time I called them, the attitude changed. That’s because the fifth is the time where they are supposed to replace the phone with a comperable model from another manufacturer, which costs them a bit of money, I suppose. They refused, and insisted we had to download updates, try it out for a few more weeks, then call back and let us know how it worked. It became obvious I was going to be stuck with a flakey, unworkable phone through June, probably until I bought another one.
I yelled. A lot.
Ultimately, I decided that if a smart phone isn’t smart enough to work, I’m not interested in having it. I didn’t have time to spend hours and hours on the phone with AT&T just to get a refurbished replacement, and Nokia offers a trade-in policy. I ditched the Epix for a new Nokia 3600 slide, one of the most wonderful devices I have ever owned and, at $300 less than the Epix, it performs almost all the same functions. After switching to Nokia, AT&T continued to fail me, but there’s more on that in the next article.
My personal take is that the smartphone craze is ending (and there are a lot of industry analysts that agree). Most smartphones cost over $400, have poor battery life, require constant reboot (even the Blackberry models), burn out in less than two years, and work poorly as a phone even on the rare occasions that they excel as a PDA. In the midst of this, Netbooks are hitting the market at $300 with celluar connectivity, run the standard operating systems you’re used to, work far better than a PDA, and are already becomming quite the rage in the business and personal market. A Netbook has the email-anywhere advantages of a smartphone along with a keyboard you can actually use with all 10 fingers.
Part three coming soon…